New Albany Sugar Shoppe
56 pearl st, new albany, in
HOME
The Candy Bar
The Chocolate Bar
French Macarons
Chocolate Dipped Oreos
The Haunted Sugar Shoppe
Just a taste
The Candy Game
The Sweet Spot
We ❤️ local!
New Albany Sugar Shoppe
56 pearl st, new albany, in
HOME
The Candy Bar
The Chocolate Bar
French Macarons
Chocolate Dipped Oreos
The Haunted Sugar Shoppe
Just a taste
The Candy Game
The Sweet Spot
We ❤️ local!
More
  • HOME
  • The Candy Bar
  • The Chocolate Bar
  • French Macarons
  • Chocolate Dipped Oreos
  • The Haunted Sugar Shoppe
  • Just a taste
  • The Candy Game
  • The Sweet Spot
  • We ❤️ local!
  • HOME
  • The Candy Bar
  • The Chocolate Bar
  • French Macarons
  • Chocolate Dipped Oreos
  • The Haunted Sugar Shoppe
  • Just a taste
  • The Candy Game
  • The Sweet Spot
  • We ❤️ local!

The Haunted Sugar Shoppe -New Albany Indiana

Ghost in Haunted Candy Shop, Connects Owner with Town’s Past

When New Albany Sugar Shoppe moved into 56 Pearl Stree, the owner had no idea she’d be working along side a baker from 1820…

Friendly Ghost Haunts Candy Shop

Beware of the ghost that lingers in the kitchen of the New Albany Sugar Shoppe.  Today we delve into the story of the murdered baker who has returned from the grave am now lingers in the back of Stevie Carper’s candy store. - Let’sScream

Fraud Alert -US Ghost Adventures

As the owner of a Haunted establishment , I want to clarify something important regarding this company We don’t endorse nor do we support US Ghost Adventures .. This is a national company pretending to be local and they are stealing the intellectual property of local ghost tours. They do not get permission from the establishment owners to use their properties on their website or marketing materials-.instead they steal the hard work of local tour operators and pass it off as their own.
Our local historian has spent years conducting meticulous research and working tirelessly to build his business from the ground up. It is incredibly disheartening to see IUS Ghost Adventures sweep in, steal his hard work, and attempt to pass his research off as their own. As a fellow small business owner, I refuse to stand by quietly while independent creators are exploited by corporate copycats. Please make sure you are supporting the authentic, locally researched history by booking directly a local guide.,



The New Albany Wicked Walk


Support local history and independent businesses by booking your next tour directly through the official New Albany Wicked Walk!

As small business owners, we at the New Albany Sugar Shoppe believe in community, authenticity, and standing up for what is right. That is why we are giving our absolute highest, most glowing endorsement to Tim and the New Albany Wicked Walk. Tim is a deeply dedicated local historian who has worked tirelessly to build his exceptional walking tour business entirely from the ground up.

Lately, a massive national corporation called US Ghost Adventures has swept into our city, plagiarizing Tim's hard work, stealing his intellectual property, and attempting to pass it off as their own. They even use the dark history of our own storefront—the macabre story of New Albany’s very first murder trial involving a baker—to profit off an unearned corporate tour. We will not stand by quietly while a giant out-of-town entity tries to muscle out a true local creator.

If you want the real, authentic, meticulously researched history of our town, don't buy into corporate imitations. Buy your tickets directly from the person who lived here and poured his heart into uncovering these stories.


Copyright © 2026 New Albany Sugar Shoppe - All Rights Reserved.

Powered by

  • HOME