New Albany Sugar Shoppe
56 pearl st, new albany, in
HOME
Just a taste
Chocolate Dipped Oreos
The Candy Bar
The Chocolate Bar
The Candy Game
French Macarons
The Haunted Sugar Shoppe
The Sweet Spot
New Albany Sugar Shoppe
56 pearl st, new albany, in
HOME
Just a taste
Chocolate Dipped Oreos
The Candy Bar
The Chocolate Bar
The Candy Game
French Macarons
The Haunted Sugar Shoppe
The Sweet Spot
More
  • HOME
  • Just a taste
  • Chocolate Dipped Oreos
  • The Candy Bar
  • The Chocolate Bar
  • The Candy Game
  • French Macarons
  • The Haunted Sugar Shoppe
  • The Sweet Spot
  • HOME
  • Just a taste
  • Chocolate Dipped Oreos
  • The Candy Bar
  • The Chocolate Bar
  • The Candy Game
  • French Macarons
  • The Haunted Sugar Shoppe
  • The Sweet Spot

Welcome to the New Albany Sugar Shoppe

    Photo Gallery

      The snozberries taste like snozberries!

      Handmade Sweets

      Saltwater Taffy Gallore!

      We take great pride in being candy makers and bakers ourselves and spend each week making a variety of handmade French Macarons, Chewy Pecan Pralines, buckeyes, bourbon balls, truffles ,chocolate dipped Oreos, cake-pops, fudge and whatever looks tasty, sweet and fun to make! 

      Saltwater Taffy Gallore!

      Saltwater Taffy Gallore!

      32 flavors of saltwater taffy and even an assortment of a sugar-free option!

      Of course, we have blueberry, chocolate, raspberry, peppermint, and cherry... but have you had raspberry lemonade, birthday cake, buckeye, or Frosted Cupcake?
      We offer 47 flavors of Taffytown Saltwater Taffy and even a SUGAR-FREE assortment pack!

      "Just Because" Gifts...

      "Just Because" Gifts...

      Do you know someone who deserves something sweet? The New Albany Sugar Shoppe offers custom gift baskets filled with candy, goodies, and collectibles. We make themed baskets like, Harry Potter, Birthday  and holiday baskets.  We can also create candy and chocolate dipped Oreo trays.  Call the shop for prices  and to place your orders.  If you have an idea for something specific, we will work with you to create the perfect gift or tray for any occasion.

      Copyright © 2025 New Albany Sugar Shoppe - All Rights Reserved.

      Powered by

      • HOME