Old Fashioned Candy Shoppe

The New Albany Sugar Shoppe is your cozy neighborhood sweet spot, packed from wall to wall with sugary treats. Our specialties include handcrafted chocolates, fresh French macarons, and over 15 flavors of chocolate-dipped Oreos. You will also find Papillon Pops, nostalgic classics, and a massive assortment of sour candy.

Stop by our Sugar Bar to choose from over 100 jars of confections, or fill a bag with 50 unique flavors of saltwater taffy. Beyond satisfying your sweet tooth, we are proud to support fellow local entrepreneurs by featuring creations from businesses like Bandz By Sam and Paige Personalized Prints.